Beat Wittmann: «Swiss Politics Suffers From a Denial of Reality»


finews.first is a forum for authors to comment on economic and financial topics.


The rivalry between the USA and China dominates geopolitics. At the same time, NATO is pursuing a clear course to support Ukraine and Europe against the common enemy, Russia; the same is true for the re-elected EU President Ursula von der Leyen and designated EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas.

All forces that directly or indirectly support Russia in its war against Ukraine and Europe must face severe consequences. With the possible election of Donald Trump, a new level of escalation is probable; first, with sanctions and tariffs against China, and secondly, with massive pressure on European NATO partners to contribute significantly more financially and militarily.

«Switzerland currently has no army that can defend and fight»

Against this backdrop, the denial of reality in Swiss politics takes on surreal dimensions, as it continues to live by the motto «What must not be, cannot be,» or in other words: «Since we do not want to provide the urgently needed financial resources for the army, we also do not see any relevant threat.» This includes labeling even prudent voices like that of Army Chief Thomas Süssli as scaremongers.

Switzerland currently has no army that can defend and fight, and at the same time, the European security situation is more threatening than ever since World War II. Moreover, a large – notably conservative – majority of the government and parliament refuses to provide the necessary financial resources for the army.

«Previous financing proposals lack a national strategy»

A ready-to-deploy army is the core of national defense. Therefore, financing the army's rearmament has absolute priority.

However, the dire state of the army requires that it receives large financial resources immediately – that is, at least 10 billion francs this year and from 2024 at least 2 percent of GDP annually. This is not a financial problem but purely a matter of political will.

Previous financing proposals from parties and politicians lack a national strategy. They reflect a patchwork of arbitrary measures to serve vested interests.
Under these premises, the army's financial needs should be secured in the short term through federal defense bonds, so-called Swiss Federal Defense Bonds, and in the long term through higher economic and productivity growth as well as institutionalized cooperation with the EU and NATO.

Issuing Swiss Federal Defense Bonds is the most efficient way for the army to procure the needed funds. Therefore, the next step would be to develop a solid decision-making basis through the Federal Department of Finance (FDF), the Swiss National Bank (SNB), and relevant Swiss banks.

«Swiss Federal Defense Bonds would also be attractive for the Swiss financial industry»

The opportunity is great to procure private and institutional financial resources on the international capital market under favorable conditions. The public budget would be minimally burdened, as the Confederation is a AAA debtor, and depending on the terms and conditions, a Swiss Federal Defense Bond in francs would be a sought-after, safe, liquid, and attractive financial investment.

The key parameters for an initial Swiss Federal Defense Bond in the fall of 2024 through a banking syndicate would be a volume of 10 billion francs; AAA rating through a Swiss government guarantee; perpetual maturity (Perpetual); different tranches for domestic and foreign investors, retail investors, and institutions; interest rate setting through an auction process.

The launch of Swiss Federal Defense Bonds would also be attractive for the Swiss financial industry, which could take a leading role in Europe regarding the emergence of a rapidly growing capital market for government and corporate debtors in the defense sector.

«Only growth offers security and prosperity»

Switzerland is far below its economic growth potential. Therefore, the described initiative is a great opportunity. This potential must be unleashed through reforms, as only growth offers security and prosperity.

Most importantly, leadership is required. This means governing and not hoping, sitting out, and reacting. Finance Minister Karin Keller-Sutter, Economic Minister Guy Parmelin, and the conservative majority in the Federal Council are responsible for ensuring a sovereign, secure, economically performing, and globally open Switzerland.


Beat Wittmann has been chairman and partner of Zurich-based financial advisory firm Porta Advisors for eight years now. His more than 30-year career in Swiss banking includes stints at both UBS and Credit Suisse as well as Clariden Leu and Julius Baer. He operated his own firm from 2009 to 2015, first independently and more recently under the Raiffeisen Group.


Previous contributions: Rudi BogniPeter KurerRolf BanzDieter RuloffWerner VogtWalter WittmannAlfred MettlerRobert HolzachCraig MurrayDavid ZollingerArthur BolligerBeat KappelerChris RoweStefan GerlachMarc LussyNuno Fernandes, Richard EggerMaurice PedergnanaMarco BargelSteve HankeUrs Schoettli, Ursula FinsterwaldStefan Kreuzkamp, Oliver BussmannMichael Benz, Albert SteckMartin Dahinden, Thomas FedierAlfred MettlerBrigitte StrebelMirjam Staub-BisangNicolas RothThorsten PolleitKim IskyanStephen DoverDenise Kenyon-RouvinezChristian DreyerKinan Khadam-Al-JameRobert HemmiAnton AffentrangerYves Mirabaud, Katharina BartFrédéric PappHans-Martin KrausGerard GuerdatMario BassiStephen ThariyanDan SteinbockRino BoriniBert FlossbachMichael HasenstabGuido SchillingWerner E. RutschDorte Bech Vizard, Katharina BartMaya BhandariJean TiroleHans Jakob RothMarco MartinelliThomas SutterTom KingWerner PeyerThomas KupferPeter KurerArturo BrisFrederic PappJames SymeDennis Larsen, Bernd Kramer, Armin JansNicolas RothHans Ulrich JostPatrick HungerFabrizio QuirighettiClaire ShawPeter FanconiAlex Wolf, Dan Steinbock, Patrick ScheurleSandro OcchilupoWill BallardNicholas YeoClaude-Alain Margelisch, Jean-François HirschelJens Pongratz, Samuel GerberPhilipp WeckherlinAnne RichardsAntoni TrenchevBenoit BarbereauPascal R. BersierShaul LifshitzKlaus BreinerAna BotínMartin GilbertJesper KollIngo RauserCarlo CapaulMarkus WinklerThomas SteinemannChristina BoeckGuillaume CompeyronMiro Zivkovic, Alexander F. WagnerEric HeymannChristoph SaxFelix BremJochen MoebertJacques-Aurélien MarcireauUrsula FinsterwaldMichel Longhini, Stefan BlumZsolt KohalmiNicolas RameletSøren BjønnessGilles PrinceSalman AhmedPeter van der WelleKen OrchardChristian GastJeffrey Bohn, Juergen BraunsteinJeff VoegeliFiona Frick, Stefan Schneider, Matthias HunnAndreas Vetsch, Fabiana Fedeli,  Kim FournaisCarole MilletSwetha RamachandranThomas StuckiNeil ShearingTom Naratil, Oliver Berger, Robert SharpsTobias MuellerFlorian WickiJean KellerNiels Lan DokyJohnny El HachemJudith BasadKatharina BartThorsten PolleitPeter SchmidKaram HindujaZsolt Kohalmi, Raphaël SurberSantosh Brivio, Mark UrquhartOlivier Kessler, Bruno CaponePeter HodyMichael BornhaeusserAgnieszka Walorska, Thomas MuellerEbrahim Attarzadeh, Marcel HostettlerHui ZhangMichael BornhaeusserReto JauchAngela AgostiniGuy de BlonayTatjana Greil CastroJean-Baptiste BerthonMarc Saint John WebbDietrich GoenemeyerMobeen TahirDidier Saint-GeorgesSerge TabachnikVega IbanezDavid Folkerts-LandauAndreas ItaMichael Welti, Fabrizio PaganiRoman BalzanTodd Saligman, Stuart DunbarCarina SchaurteBirte Orth-FreeseGun WooLamara von AlbertiniRamon VogtAndrea HoffmannNiccolò GarzelliDarren WilliamsBenjamin BöhnerMike JudithJared CookHenk GrootveldRoman GausNicolas FallerAnna StünziThomas Höhne-SparborthFabrizio PaganiGuy de BlonayJan BoudewijnsSean HagertyAlina DonetsSébastien GalyRoman von AhFernando FernándezGeorg von WyssStefan BannwartAndreas BrittFrédéric LerouxNick PlatjouwRolando GrandiPhilipp KaupkeGérard PiaskoBrad SlingerlendDieter WermuthGrégoire BordierThomas Signer, Gianluca GerosaChristine HoustonManuel Romera RoblesFabian KäslinClaudia KraazMarco HuwilerLukas ZihlmannSherif MamdouhHarald PreisslerTaimur HyatPhilipp CottierAndreas HerrmannCamille VialMarcus Hüttinger, Serge BeckAlannah BeerStéphane MonierAshley SimmonsLars JaegerShanna Strauss-FrankBertrand Binggeli, Marionna WegensteinGeorge Muzinich, Jian Shi CortesiRazan NasserNicolas ForestJoerg RuetschiReto JauchBernardo BrunschwilerCharles-Henry MonchauPhilip Adler, Ha DuongTeodoro CoccaBeat WittmannJan Brzezek, Nicolas Mousset, Beat WeissPascal MischlerAndrew IsbesterKonrad HummlerJan BeckersMartin VeltenKatharine NeissClaude BaumannDaniel RoartyKubilay YalcinRobert AlmeidaKarin M. KlossekMarc TavernerCharlie T. MungerDaniel KoblerPatrick StauberColin Vidal, Anna Rosenber, Judith Wallenstein, Adriano Lucatelli, Daniel Goleman, Val Olson, Brice Prunas, Francesco Magistra, Frances Weir, Luis Maldonado, Francesco Magistra, Nadège Lesueur-Pène, Massimo Pedrazzini, Eric Sarasin, David Ellis, Dina Ting, Christopher Gannatti, Shaniel Ramjee, Mihkel Vitsur, Nannette Hechler-Fayd’herbe, Ralph Ebert, Chris Cottorone, Francesco Mandalà, Mariolina Esposito, Maryann Umoren Selfe, Dominique Gerster, Marc Arand, Christian Kälin, Nadège Dufossé, Benjamin Melman, Brigitte Kaps, Florin Baeriswyl, Marc Reinhardt, and Thomas Holderegger.